If the amygdala in the brain can cause anxiety, why can't sufferers just hav!
Question: If the amygdala in the brain can cause anxiety, why can't sufferers just have it removed!?
It is thought this part is the nerve centre for all fears and panics, so why not get it removed!. They can help people with parkinson's etc, so why not that!?Www@Answer-Health@Com
Answers:
Hello there,
The amygdala can be removed and are occasionally as a treatment for certain severe types of epilepsy!. Their function is complex and associated with emotional learning and recognising emotional responses in other people!. Removing them is not something to do at all casually!. Good luck!.Www@Answer-Health@Com
The amygdala can be removed and are occasionally as a treatment for certain severe types of epilepsy!. Their function is complex and associated with emotional learning and recognising emotional responses in other people!. Removing them is not something to do at all casually!. Good luck!.Www@Answer-Health@Com
Amygdala has been found to be associated with various things and not just anxiety!. It is associated with memory, autonomic functions, sexual behaviour and emotional learning (to name a few) therefore without it these functions may deteriorate!. Further more, anxiety has not just been associated with the amygdala but also the hippocampus and other areas in the forebrain therefore you'd have to remove all this just to make sure and this would have detrimental affects on the person plus would be rediculously expensive for a disorder that in the majority can be treated with beta blockers and other meds as well as psychological interventions like cognitive behavioural therapy!. Also anxiety has a beneficial purpose as its healthy to fear things that are detrimental to our species survival and without the amygdala we would not be able to learn to avoid things like poisonous snakes, which is aided by anxiety!.Www@Answer-Health@Com
This is a silly question, to be honest!.
1!. Fear and anxiety can be necessary, and healthy emotions!.
2!. The amygdala does more than just make you anxious!.
3!. It's somewhat heavyhanded as a cure for anxiety, and risky in general!.Www@Answer-Health@Com
1!. Fear and anxiety can be necessary, and healthy emotions!.
2!. The amygdala does more than just make you anxious!.
3!. It's somewhat heavyhanded as a cure for anxiety, and risky in general!.Www@Answer-Health@Com
I dont think you should remove something like that!. There could be some spiritual reason for anxiety!. Ive had alot anxiety in my life but I think there is a bit more too it!. Something maybe in your past that needs to be confronted or something right now!.Www@Answer-Health@Com
1) Because brain surgery is highly complicated and is associated with a lot of risks!.
2) Because the Amygdala does more than just cause anxiety!. To remove it for one reason only goes against the concept of Holism!.Www@Answer-Health@Com
2) Because the Amygdala does more than just cause anxiety!. To remove it for one reason only goes against the concept of Holism!.Www@Answer-Health@Com
Interesting idea, but all parts of the body are multifunctioning, its a case of 'throwing out the baby with the bath water' as they say!
You'd undoubtedly find some unwanted side effectsWww@Answer-Health@Com
You'd undoubtedly find some unwanted side effectsWww@Answer-Health@Com
Im going through alot of anxiety right now!. It's just part of being human, leave it as it is!. God put it there for a reason!.Www@Answer-Health@Com
As humans we need anxiety for certain situation and to have the amygdala removed could get us run over by a busWww@Answer-Health@Com
youd be a really boring person!!!Www@Answer-Health@Com
youd be brain dead!. certain amount of panic is good!. it keeps you going!.Www@Answer-Health@Com
!.!.!.plus it would screw up your ability to learnWww@Answer-Health@Com
why would you want an operation where the risks are so high and MRSA is ripeWww@Answer-Health@Com