My friend is 12, weighs 128 pounds, is 4'10, and plays alot of soccer. Is sh!


Question: Ok, she eats healthy, has muscle, weighs 128 pounds. She thinks she is fat. She weighed a lot in third grade, she lost a lot of weight. Is she fat or overweight?


Answers: Ok, she eats healthy, has muscle, weighs 128 pounds. She thinks she is fat. She weighed a lot in third grade, she lost a lot of weight. Is she fat or overweight?

shes athletic ! and besides that, she is 12, so in a couple of years since shes athletic, im guessing shell be at least 5'5 .. and if your only supposed to gain three lbs a year if you eat healthy..so..16 lets say.. 3 lbs times 4 years 16 5'5 140...thats not fat at all...my friends gf is 5'5 140 and shes hot =]

uhh kinda im like 5'4 and i dont even weigh 128 pounds

no it is probably muscle.

Not really. If she's pretty muscular, muscle weighs MORE than fat.... so I'd say she's just fit. :)

I'm 5-10 (so a foot taller) and weigh 135 (seven pounds more) and am also an serious athlete (lots of muscle)

Yes :) she is one fat mother ****** :)

I have an inclination that "your friend" is you ... considering your avatar and name ... *soccer girl* She's (you're) not fat ... it's also a bit hard to determine "fat" my height and weight. People who are athletic often times weigh more because muscle is heavier than fat.

well..I'm 12, I weigh 110 pounds, and I'm 5'1, soooo...idk if she's fat, the weight might just be muscle..so, I don't think she's fat, she may not be skinny...but not fat.

nope,. just buff,built, and in shape !:)

My first instinct was to say yes, because i'm 13, 5'1, and I only weigh 96lbs.
but, I have absolutly not muscle. If she plays soccer a lot, she's got to have a lot of muscle. and muscle weighs a lot more than fat does.
I'd say no.

i dont think she is fat, then again i dont even no here. And can't point fingerd cause im one fat girl myself. lol 5'2 and a half and im 14! and i weigh 139!! but i think she just have musle to play a soccer player cause like the muscle builds like under fat which is hard to like get rid of. :O well hope i answered your question... toodles :)

didn't give much info
i am 13, 4'8 and weigh 121.3 pounds
I'm a ladies size 5 (AUS)
and I'm always running jumping skipping and being active.
I'm The shortest in my year and The 5th heaviest including boys!!!!
my friends are always telling me I'm to thin!!!
you cant tell by wight if someone is fat or obese

Should it matter? As long as she eats healthy, is physically active and is happy with herself she is healthy.





The consumer health information on answer-health.com is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for medical advice or treatment for any medical conditions.
The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
Copyright © 2007-2011 answer-health.com -   Terms of Use -   Contact us

Health Categories