What! women in bathroom for 2 years and.......?!


Question: If you heard about this incident that happened about 2 weeks or more ago....The lady that was stuck to the toilet seat for so long that it grew to her....Do you think it was fair to charge her boyfriend with mistreatment of an adult when she was an adult her self and allow this to happen???? she was not force to stay in the bathroom nor was she tied up in any way. Opinions please :)


Answers: If you heard about this incident that happened about 2 weeks or more ago....The lady that was stuck to the toilet seat for so long that it grew to her....Do you think it was fair to charge her boyfriend with mistreatment of an adult when she was an adult her self and allow this to happen???? she was not force to stay in the bathroom nor was she tied up in any way. Opinions please :)

I do know this story. The woman was ill and her boyfriend was her caregiver. Why else would they be charging him? If she was capable of taking care of herself then he wouldnt get anyhting. She had bedsores that opened and seeped and thats how the seat got stuck to her. Poor woman. If her boyfriend could'nt have handled it, he should have gotten help a long time ago, like 2 yrs ago.

hahahaha, i lauged so HARD when i heard this story, they must've been SO white trash,
i think they should both be shot for being stupid

IVE NEVER HEARD THAT!! THATSINTERESTING

I think she wanted to get her boyfriend charged.

Wasn't her boyfriend the one who called in for someone to help?
That's not mistreatment.

I don't know why she was on the toilet for 2 years though - anyone know?

Yes.

Clearly she was disturbed. I would think that after a few days (or even if he gave it a week or two) he should have called for help. He was negligent

I think the boyfriend is to blame becausehe should have contacted someone, that she was stuck!!!

he's guilty of neglect...

First of all, A toilet seat cannot "grow" to you
Second of all, since she wasn't tied up or anything there shouldn't be any charge but the boyfriend should of called someone to help because its unsual for a person to sit on a toilet seat for 2 years.

dude
that came out way long ago
but i did in my S.S. class


she stupid
and the boyfriend who did nothing is too

TOO FUNNY! Charge them both!

thats unfairr to the
boyfriend

yeh thats dumb because why would the boyfriend be blamed for her staying in the bathroom for two years.
its her own fault, and NOONE told her to sit on the tolet for that long, there is a shower and stuff to.

Omg yeah i heard of that! Although i DONT know the whole entire story, and i'm not like a lawyer or anything, I don't think its right to charge her boyfriend. Unless she has a mental disability, she can make choices and obviously it was her choice to stay on the pot! lol!! that story is kinda funny btw

I don't necessarily agree with the idea that the boyfriend should be charged, but I do see the reasoning behind it. He COULD have called someone rather than catering to her obvious disorder and letting it go untreated.

I don't think he should have been charged with anything. Like you said she was a grown adult and if she didn't want to get off the toilet that's her problem!

Plus from what I hear he asked her to please get off and he also fed her everyday soooo I don't know why he's being charged for anything!

classic case of mental illness and stupidity rolled into one

You didn't hear this on April 1, by any chance? Ooops, pardon me.

The woman was a dependent adult. The boyfriend was arrested for indecent exposure.

http://www.dailymail.com/News/NationandW...

What happened, I havent heard of this, have you got a link to the story?

Well if she has a mental problem or if she has gotten to the point that this man mentally controlled her then, yes, I would blame her boyfriend for mistreatment. There are alot of women out there that let men control them, even to the point of abuse.

We don't know all of the details, so it's hard for me to choose. I've heard two sides, and both have been on the news and also, we must remember, we don't know EVERYTHING about it. There MAY BE MORE TO IT!.

it's pretty ridiculous
but like
at what point do you not find it ridiculous that your girlfriend refuses to leave the bathroom
i mean maybe a few days
even that's pushing it
but TWO YEARS?
like it's not his fault
but seriously
he should've done something.

Now my question is were did that poor guy take a crap if she was on the toliet for two years?

She is an adult, yes, but she was clearly not in a fit state of mind and she was reliant on the boyfriend to take care of her. The fact that he waited so long to get her help was negligent.

charging him is stupid.

I wouldn't have let her stay in the bathroom, myself. But I don't see the crime if one adult lets another do something weird, like not leave the bathroom.

yea i heard that , and yes she should be charged..he could at lest ask someone to come and talk to her not let her sit then and suffer..cause i am sure she wasnt happy..but she was just scared !

he shouldn't be charged because it was her decision and he didn't do anything to harm her. I think that he is an idiot for not persuading her to get off the toilet nor leaving her, but none of that stuff is illegal. So no i don't think he should be charged.

i read that article and YES! Obviously she had a mental condition and he shouldn't have watched her rott away rather putting her in a home would have been appropriate. Mistreatment and if you think its not how would you feel stuck to a toilet not mentally well enough to leave.

I've heard about this story. It's tragic, I guess. I would hope my significant other would never allow this to happen. She was obviously obese before this one day when she just decided to stay in the bathroom... and then it just continued. I think it may be criminal if her boyfriend hid the situation, and prevented her from getting help.

I don't believe that story. "It grew to her"..

What did veins grow out of her legs into the seat?

But yes, I think it was fair to charge him. Trust me, after a couple hours of my woman in the bathroom not coming out, I'm going in there whether she likes it or not and finding out what's wrong.

If she couldn't get off the toilet after really trying where I started to feel funky, (like in 3-4 hours) I'd probably call the ambulance.

2 years, charge him.

I would need more facts, but what has been told already i would say it was her fault for sitting there to long and why didnt he try to help???





The consumer health information on answer-health.com is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for medical advice or treatment for any medical conditions.
The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
Copyright © 2007-2011 answer-health.com -   Terms of Use -   Contact us

Health Categories